Monday, August 13, 2018

Social Democracy vs. Democratic Socialism

Sheri Berman had a very interesting article in the Sunday Outlook section of the Washington Post comparing social democracy with democratic socialism. I think Berman is a little hard on today's democratic socialists, most of whom are really just left-ish social democrats, rather than true blue democratic socialists committed to replacing capitalism with a different economic system. In this sense, I think she errs in comparing today's democratic socialists with the genuinely revolutionary socialists who stayed out of the Third (Communist) International and briefly formed their own international (sometimes referred to as the "two and a half international"). The democratic socialists of today don't match up very well, either ideologically or in terms of social base, with those socialists of yesteryear.
Most democratic socialists today are really mostly concerned--here and in Europe--with pushing the left into a more confrontational attitude toward neoliberalism and toward the adoption of larger-scale reforms. That's pretty far from the revolutionary replacement of capitalism with socialism. Still, Berman does raise some important questions for those democratic socialists who are explicitly committed to replacing, rather than reforming, capitalism. .She asks:
"What does the DSA’s goal of socialism actually mean? If abolishing capitalism is its goal, as its adherents say, how are the growth, efficiency and innovation that are the prerequisites for redistribution to be achieved? And if reforms can’t create a better world (“Today’s democratic socialists don’t see positive policy reforms as something we’ll stack up until one day, voilà!, we have socialism,” as one democratic socialist wrote in Vox), then how is socialism to be achieved? Is democracy, even when flawed, a means or an end? Will democratic socialists prioritize democracy if the votes for a “socialist future” do not materialize? Will they eschew the compromises and alliances necessary to protect democracy? The unwillingness of Jean-Luc Mélenchon to support President Emanuel Macron in the French presidential elections, and the refusal by some American leftists to support Hillary Clinton, come to mind, as does the willingness of some democratic socialists to consider running outside the Democratic Party. And will democratic socialists accept the trade-offs and bridge-building necessary to win elections? Or is compromise, as [one democratic socialist] put it, antithetical to truly fighting “for the working class and marginalized”?"
Good questions all! Or, put another way, was this guy the main man or a shameless capitulator to the bourgeousie? Every generation must answer this all-important question!


  1. The writing work is remarkable, and I am so pleased that you were able to share this article here.I am sure that if I ask enough people, they'll agree with me, too
    currency-converter-box-by-autoketing, currency converter portable

  2. Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive read anything like this before. So nice to search out any individual with some original thoughts on this subject. realy thank you for starting this up. this website is one thing that’s wanted on the web, somebody with a bit of originality. useful job for bringing something new to the internet!

    sales pop master free
    sales pop master app

  3. I guess you are a smart cookie because of your knowledge and insight.They are really good for everyone. I want to send a thank to you. I usually read them.
    free game Battle for the Galaxy Break The Cup For boy Toon Cup 2017

  4. Good day. I discovered your online journal utilizing msn.I’d choose to make use of some with the content on my blog whether or not you don’t mind.Magnificent work.I trust you would not have reservations if I placed a link here? game online Tomb Runner Mommy Elsa Baby Caring online game Blocky Craft Police Squad play for free


  5. food games free
    basketball games 2019
    soccer free online
    Good day. I discovered your online journal utilizing msn.I’d choose to make use of some with the content on my blog whether or not you don’t mind.Magnificent work.I trust you would not have reservations if I placed a link here?

  6. jogo io online
    free online friv Games
    play 2 player games
    Pleasant online journal and totally exceptional. You can improve yet despite everything I say this perfect.Keep striving generally advantageous

  7. Hi! Thanks for the great information you have provided! Any way I'll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon.
    miniclip games for girls,
    a10 games online,
    Jogos grátis

  8. This is a post that we all should read at least once, it's great, wish you success in the next blog. I like this post because it contains a lot of useful information to read, maybe everyone will like me.
    kizi 4 girl games, friv jogos, pbs jocuri online

  9. So first you soak your Red Wheat Berries, for 8-24 hours. You can buy Red Wheat Berries at your local health food store, often in the bulk section. And yes wheatgrass is gluten free. I too, was concerned, but after searching around and asking a licensed dietitian friend in the area, the grass itself does not contain any gluten, only the kernel, and in juicing wheatgrass you only juice the grass, so yay!
    games online for kids
    jogos friv gratis 2019
    jogos games online

  10. The true test will come when I tell them the white on the outside of the meat is a natural edible mold called Penicillim. If they keep eating despite this then I know we have an undisputed winner.
    kizi 4 girl games
    friv jogos
    free online friv Games